here are some of my NYC tops thus far (i am still looking for my favorite...)
-Ear Inn 7/10 (patty's got a good kick, i asked gary the owner if they add an excessive amount of black pepper as the secret, he didn't confirm. buns were dry last time though)
-Superiority Burger 8/10 (i have yet to try a whole one by myself bc friends always insist on SHARING but that won't happen next time)
-Raouls 6.5/10 (way too fucking messy for that price... felt feral... yet tasty)
Thai Diner 7/10 (i love going to asian restaurants just for american-style burgers)
-Burger Joint 6/10 (great spot for selfies in the hotel hallway before/after)
Shake Shack 8/10 (how can you not)
Corner Bistro 5/10 (it was fine)
-J.G. Melon 5/10 (overrated)
-White Mana in NJ 8/10 (maybe doesn't count)
i'm partial to smash style and prefer sandwiches with structure sans the bulky patty BS... people have also suggested burgs from Long Island Bar, Minetta, Bernie's, and Lexington Candy Shop (thank you/you're welcome)