A brief anecdote to preface this (skip to get straight to the philosophy):
Today a team member and I (building a business) met with an expert in his respective field to ask some questions. After a little explanatory back-and-forth, it was clear he had a complete lack of knowledge of our sector, and had only understood the description of our project on a superficial level. Nonetheless, he proceeded to spend most of the time āpushing backā, and therefore was unable to offer much insight that we could use.
āāāā
Critique/judgment without understanding is invalid ā period. This is confusing to some critics/would-be critics/people because they conflate the accumulation of knowledge with the skill of understanding. Letās say youāre a music critic ā you know lots of stuff about many kinds of music, many eras, etc. One day something comes along your desk, you pop it on, and it sounds a bit odd. Youāve never heard of the artist beforeā¦ it sounds vaguely similar to something you know of ā sure, letās compare it to that, I guess. In this moment, you may not realize that you have a blindspot. Maybe you donāt yet understand the cultural or aesthetic movement this piece of music is born from because it doesnāt overlap with your breadth of knowledge (even if itās very wide). Your prior knowledge may inform your ability to understand, but it doesnāt replace it. A real critic will take the time, as their duty, to understand as best they can before they make any critique. Anyone else isnāt a real critic.
This goes for everything and everyone, not just professional or expert criticism. Itās true on an individual level, a social/cultural level, a political level, etc.
Now especially, everyoneās a critic ā and thatās both great and terrible/terrifying. Criticism/judgment are perfectly valid and useful forms of human expression if and only if you seek to understand beforehand.
So, we can think about that from the perspective of giving criticism and, of course, receiving it. Being open to criticism is a massively important quality to develop, but if someone hasnāt made an effort to understand you/your idea, their critiques can go into the trash can. š®
āāāā
š©µš©µ